Home page of BPDFamily.com, online relationship supportMember registration here
May 22, 2015, 04:56:41 AM *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Moderators: DreamGirl, EaglesJuJu, lbjnltx, Kwamina, livednlearned, Mutt, Suzn, Turkish, Waverider   
Advisors: cosmonaut, formflier, jhkbuzz, maxen, Mike-X, Reforming, Ripped Heart
  Directory Guidelines Glossary   Boards   Help Please Donate Login Register  
bing
Highly Recommended Book ... Alan Fruzzetti. PhD co-founder of the NEA-BPD Family Connections program adapts DBT tools for use by couples. Learn how to analyze conflict "triggers" and then identify more constructive ways to handle them. Also learn to tackle resentment -- a mental process in which we repeatedly relive painful things in ways that affect us mentally, emotionally, physiologically and spiritually.
62
Pages: [1]   Go Down
  Print  
Author Topic: Correct response to the end of Silent Treatment  (Read 3844 times)
Aaargh

Offline Offline

Posts: 5


« on: April 28, 2011, 05:36:49 AM »


I am currently being silently treated, complete with sleeping on separate beds. This has now gone on for close to 2 weeks, which is long even by the standards of my undiagnosed wife. I am quite hopeful that this will end soon. I have seen some positive signs, (e.g. responding to hello). Normally I would initiatie a conversation at this point whic would involve me apologising, but I am sure that just re-inforces the behaviour.

What do folks suggest is the correct behaviour at this point. My options are:

1 - Wait for w to initiate conversation. I might be waiting a few more weeks. Part of me thinks this would be giving into anger.

2 - Initiate conversation and hug her - validating her feelings etc. Worried that this doesn't link her behaviour to any consequences, and doesn't acknowledge the hurt that I have gone through over these weeks.

3 - talk to her about how I felt over the last couple of weeks. Get ready for anther two weeks of Silent treatment.


Thoughts and advice much appreciated ?

---------------------------------------------------------------------

I am new here and have just discovered BPD - posted an intro on http://BPDfamily.com/message_board/index.php?topic=144699.0
Logged
Steph
Distinguished Member
Emeritus
*
Offline Offline

Gender: Female
Posts: 7847



« Reply #1 on: April 28, 2011, 07:24:55 AM »

 Welcome! I am glad you found your way here.

The best way we have found to deal with the Silent Treatment is none of the above.

What we suggest is to live your life..do what you enjoy, go to work, see friends, movies, work out, go to the dentist, etc...in other words, be good to yourself and dont engage in the silent treatment at all. Be polite to her, kind, etc, but let it be HER thing, not yours. If shes silent, then she is..it wont stop you from your life. Dont engage it.

  Be sure to start to read the lessons, to your right. This is a great place to get the groundwork in place and begin to understand BPD>

What is it that causes you to believe your wife has BPD?


Steph
Logged


Annaleigh
*******
Offline Offline

Gender: Female
Posts: 2521


« Reply #2 on: April 28, 2011, 07:36:41 AM »

My H didn't rage at me for the most part, silent treatment was his preferred method of punishment.  With rages, you walk away and refuse to engage.  Turns out that is the best response to the silent treatment.  Go about your business and refuse to engage.  Go to the gym, go for a drive, read a good book, go for a walk, watch a movie, meet up with friends, take care of yourself and leave them to their tantrum.  Doing the right thing

Oh, and Welcome!  Glad you found us and sorry you are dealing with this.  Empathy
Logged
Aaargh

Offline Offline

Posts: 5


« Reply #3 on: April 28, 2011, 07:54:08 PM »


Maybe I didnt ask the question clearly, it was about what to do when you are getting clear signals that the silent treatment is ending.

I understand now that feeling sorry for yourself this whole period and allowing yourself to be punished is not a good idea. (Why I didn't figure this out over the 7 years now seems like such a waste)

But what to do when the silent treatment ends, e.g. wife joined me for breakfast this morning and started talking normally, as if nothing had happened over the past two weeks.

Do I also pretend that nothing happened? This seems counter intuitive. I also worry that when I try to set a boundary, there will be a denial that there ever was this silent treatment.

Or do I point out that what she was doing wasn't lost on me. This carries the risk that she will see that her punishment of was having an effect and may re-inforce the behaviour.

Which of the two evils is lesser ?
Logged
Steph
Distinguished Member
Emeritus
*
Offline Offline

Gender: Female
Posts: 7847



« Reply #4 on: April 28, 2011, 08:23:26 PM »


Maybe I didnt ask the question clearly, it was about what to do when you are getting clear signals that the silent treatment is ending.

I understand now that feeling sorry for yourself this whole period and allowing yourself to be punished is not a good idea. (Why I didn't figure this out over the 7 years now seems like such a waste)

But what to do when the silent treatment ends, e.g. wife joined me for breakfast this morning and started talking normally, as if nothing had happened over the past two weeks.

Do I also pretend that nothing happened? This seems counter intuitive. I also worry that when I try to set a boundary, there will be a denial that there ever was this silent treatment.

Or do I point out that what she was doing wasn't lost on me. This carries the risk that she will see that her punishment of was having an effect and may re-inforce the behaviour.

Which of the two evils is lesser ?

 I would advise simply going about your life. The less it impacts you, the less interest she will have in using it again, against you. Have fun when shes quiet...at least there isnt rging,. ya? Live your life and let her have her " hold my breath until I turn blue" moment. Dont give it attention, before, during, or after..and get busy so that it wont impact you.

Keep in mind, what you have done in the past hasnt worked, has it? So..pretend shes 4 and pouting..and go on with your life.

Steph
Logged


jardin
*****
Offline Offline

Posts: 874



« Reply #5 on: April 28, 2011, 11:44:55 PM »


Maybe I didnt ask the question clearly, it was about what to do when you are getting clear signals that the silent treatment is ending.

I understand now that feeling sorry for yourself this whole period and allowing yourself to be punished is not a good idea. (Why I didn't figure this out over the 7 years now seems like such a waste)

But what to do when the silent treatment ends, e.g. wife joined me for breakfast this morning and started talking normally, as if nothing had happened over the past two weeks.

Do I also pretend that nothing happened? This seems counter intuitive. I also worry that when I try to set a boundary, there will be a denial that there ever was this silent treatment.

Or do I point out that what she was doing wasn't lost on me. This carries the risk that she will see that her punishment of was having an effect and may re-inforce the behaviour.

Which of the two evils is lesser ?

Can you find a middle ground between these two perspectives?  Right now, she is coming down, stabilizing.  By forcing a conversation or imposing your feelings on her, you weaken the foundation that she is slowly working to re-build.  If she's not ready for the conversation, almost anything you say will be invalidating and she very well may respond with more anger...or more silence. 

On the other hand, at some point, it very well may be appropriate to address this behavior.  After time, and when things get back to some level of calm, it may be completely ok to say to her...you know, I'd like to talk about something...I care about your feelings and I know sometimes you get very upset and need some time to yourself; when those times happen, I am ok, but I still need you to at least be responsive to conversations about (kids, home, work, etc). 

At the right time and place, she can be receptive to this.  It doesn't mean that she won't get upset at some level, but she will be better able to hear it.  As long as you stay calm and don't defend your need, things may generally remain ok.  In contrast, at this time, she may be very quick to defense, very on guard.  Hearing you may be very hard and what's the point in talking if the recipient isn't there to hear.  So, the question is, can you let this sit until the right time?  Until you regain some closeness and calm?  That is not walking on eggshells, it's being smart and it's accepting and respecting the constraints of the relationship. 
Logged

Our integrity sells for so little, but it is all we really have.  It is the very last inch of us.  And within that inch, we are free. - Valerie's Letter


2015 Community Sponsors
Keeping BPDFamily on the air
We are all appreciative of the thoughtful men and women who provide the support, education, and brotherhood that keep BPDFamily on the air and make a difference in our lives. To all, thank you for this wonderful resource.

1989
123Phoebe
4kidz
A maze
Achaya
Adelheid
adventurer
aeoma
Alex86
alf
All4BVM
antifragile
arlers
Aurora7
Aussie JJ
Aussieman
babyducks
BatMasterson
beatup
Being Mindful
Bhodidharma
billypilgrim
BlackandBlue
blissful_camper
bluetooth
bobbyvp
Bookworm77
Boss302
bpdfamfan
bpdRelife
CalledaPerson
captain4464
Carebearx2m
careman
Caresaboutsomeonelikethis
Cat Familiar
catclaw
catnap
caughtnreleased
cehlers55
chooselove
Chosen
chump
claudiaduffy
cleotokos
clydegriffith
Cmjo
cobwebfaery
ColdEthyl
confusedwoman
Conundrum
CookieMom
corraline
coworkerfriend
Cumulus
dar
Dark star
DearBFF
Dire Wolf
doubleAries
downwhim
draptemp
drummerboy
Dutched
DyingLove
easternmom
Elpis
Emelie Emelie
emoinferno
enlighten me
Ex_CB_Partner
F150
findingmyselfagain
flowerpath
foggydew
ForeverDad
forget-me-not
Frankcostello
Free2Bee
freedom33
FreeMeGal
friskey
fromheeltoheal
Gagrl
GeekyGirl
gettin-unstuck
gloveman
goldylamont
Grey Kitty
gsm42
HappyChappy
HappyNihilist
harnettr
Harri
HealingSpirit
Heartandsole
heartandwhole
Heldfast
Heshie
hithere
Hope26
hope2727
howcanI?
imataloss
In Pain
inkling16
Inside
Intent_to_learn
Japeslee
jaynebrain
jellibeans
Jessica84
jjclark
Johnjm
joolz29
joyjoyjoy
JRT
jthorpejr
JulesC
kaer
kappa
KarenDH
kc sunshine
Keep
KeepOnGoing
kelti1972
kiddfei
kidsteele
kj1234
KQuestionsItAll
Kwamina
landj
landofoz
Learning Fast
Leelou
lemon flower
lever
Linda Maria
lipstick
lm911
Lmls
Love Is Not Enough
Loveisfree
lovenature
Loveofhislife
Lucky One
maid
malibu4x
MammaMia
maric
maxen
mdg2101
Mel1968
Memorial Donation
Memorial Donation
Memorial Donation
Memorial Donation
Memorial Donation
Memorial Donation
Memorial Donation
Memorial Donation
Memorial Donation
Memorial Donation
Memorial Donation
Memorial Donation
Memorial Donation
Memorial Donation
mercurious
Mercury2Pluto
mggt
michel71
Mike76
Mom919
Mommy108
momtara
Mr Hollande
Mutt
Narellan
NeedHelpPls
newlifeBPDfree
NewWays
nochangeinsight
Nope
NorthernGirl
oblivian2013
oceaneyes
Olivia_D
outside9x
overcomer
P.F.Change
pallavirajsinghani
Panda39
paperlung
patientandclear
Patty
picturelady
Pingo
PinkieV
Pou
preciousme
Progress Not Perfection
propunchingbag
qcarolr
qkslvrgirl
Rapt Reader
raytamtay3
really???
Recooperating
Reforming
ReluctantSurvivor
rickdeckard
Ridingthewaves
Rifka
rj47
rollercoaster24
Ross O
sanemom
Saro
Scarlet Phoenix
schwing
SCM
seahorse
SES
Sheed
Should I stay or...
simpleman
sirius
SistersKeeper
Skip
Soulslider
Southern_Belle
SpringInMyStep
Sshilli
SSJ0603
stargazer3
StayOrLeave15
stupafly
Surg_Bear
Surnia
swampped
sweetheart
swiftkick
Take2
Tamara96
Theo41
thereishope
Tiepje3
TigerEye
ToLiveAgain
toomanytears
trappedinlove
tryingtohelp
trytrytry
Turkish
tuum est61
twojaybirds
ugghh
Up In the Air
vbor
Vindi
vre
waverider
Whichwayisup
whirlpoollife
White_Lily
WindReader
winston72
Witchway
Yaffle
yeeter
zaqsert
zenwexler
Pay it forward Here

If you made a donation and your name does not appear on this list here , please contact us so that we may confirm that the payment was properly credited to BPDFamily.

Pages: [1]   Go Up
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

index.php?topic=56206.msg913187#msg913187
Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.10 | SMF © 2006-2015, Simple Machines LLC Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!