Home page of BPDFamily.com, online relationship supportMember registration here
February 25, 2017, 01:05:37 AM *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Statistics on BPD Relationships: Read here
Moderators: heartandwhole, Meili, once removed
Member support team: DreamGirl, gotbushels, joeramabeme, rfriesen, Turkish, Woolspinner2000
  Directory Guidelines Glossary   Boards   Help Please Donate Login Register  
Video, Audio, and Research for Member Critique
100
Caretaking - What is it all about?
Margalis Fjelstad, PhD
Blame - why we do it?
Brené Brown, PhD
Family dynamics matter.
Alan Fruzzetti, PhD
A perspective on BPD
Ivan Speilberg, PhD
Pages: [1]   Go Down
  Print  
Author Topic: Correct response to the end of Silent Treatment  (Read 4757 times)
Aaargh

Offline Offline

Posts: 5


« on: April 28, 2011, 05:36:49 AM »



I am currently being silently treated, complete with sleeping on separate beds. This has now gone on for close to 2 weeks, which is long even by the standards of my undiagnosed wife. I am quite hopeful that this will end soon. I have seen some positive signs, (e.g. responding to hello). Normally I would initiatie a conversation at this point whic would involve me apologising, but I am sure that just re-inforces the behaviour.

What do folks suggest is the correct behaviour at this point. My options are:

1 - Wait for w to initiate conversation. I might be waiting a few more weeks. Part of me thinks this would be giving into anger.

2 - Initiate conversation and hug her - validating her feelings etc. Worried that this doesn't link her behaviour to any consequences, and doesn't acknowledge the hurt that I have gone through over these weeks.

3 - talk to her about how I felt over the last couple of weeks. Get ready for anther two weeks of Silent treatment.


Thoughts and advice much appreciated ?

---------------------------------------------------------------------

I am new here and have just discovered BPD - posted an intro on https://bpdfamily.com/message_board/index.php?topic=144699.0

Logged
RELATIONSHIP PROBLEM SOLVING
This is a high level discussion board for discussing effective actions for solving ongoing and day-to-day relationship conflicts. Members are welcomed to express frustration but must seek constructive solutions to problems.
This is not a place for relationship "stay" or "leave" discussions. Please read the specific guidelines for this  group by (clicking here).
Steph
Retired Staff
*******
Offline Offline

Gender: Female
Posts: 7846



« Reply #1 on: April 28, 2011, 07:24:55 AM »

 Welcome! I am glad you found your way here.

The best way we have found to deal with the Silent Treatment is none of the above.

What we suggest is to live your life..do what you enjoy, go to work, see friends, movies, work out, go to the dentist, etc...in other words, be good to yourself and dont engage in the silent treatment at all. Be polite to her, kind, etc, but let it be HER thing, not yours. If shes silent, then she is..it wont stop you from your life. Dont engage it.

  Be sure to start to read the lessons, to your right. This is a great place to get the groundwork in place and begin to understand BPD>

What is it that causes you to believe your wife has BPD?


Steph
Logged



Annaleigh
*******
Offline Offline

Gender: Female
Posts: 2516


« Reply #2 on: April 28, 2011, 07:36:41 AM »

My H didn't rage at me for the most part, silent treatment was his preferred method of punishment.  With rages, you walk away and refuse to engage.  Turns out that is the best response to the silent treatment.  Go about your business and refuse to engage.  Go to the gym, go for a drive, read a good book, go for a walk, watch a movie, meet up with friends, take care of yourself and leave them to their tantrum.  Doing the right thing

Oh, and Welcome!  Glad you found us and sorry you are dealing with this.   
Logged
Aaargh

Offline Offline

Posts: 5


« Reply #3 on: April 28, 2011, 07:54:08 PM »



Maybe I didnt ask the question clearly, it was about what to do when you are getting clear signals that the silent treatment is ending.

I understand now that feeling sorry for yourself this whole period and allowing yourself to be punished is not a good idea. (Why I didn't figure this out over the 7 years now seems like such a waste)

But what to do when the silent treatment ends, e.g. wife joined me for breakfast this morning and started talking normally, as if nothing had happened over the past two weeks.

Do I also pretend that nothing happened? This seems counter intuitive. I also worry that when I try to set a boundary, there will be a denial that there ever was this silent treatment.

Or do I point out that what she was doing wasn't lost on me. This carries the risk that she will see that her punishment of was having an effect and may re-inforce the behaviour.

Which of the two evils is lesser ?
Logged
Steph
Retired Staff
*******
Offline Offline

Gender: Female
Posts: 7846



« Reply #4 on: April 28, 2011, 08:23:26 PM »

Maybe I didnt ask the question clearly, it was about what to do when you are getting clear signals that the silent treatment is ending.

I understand now that feeling sorry for yourself this whole period and allowing yourself to be punished is not a good idea. (Why I didn't figure this out over the 7 years now seems like such a waste)

But what to do when the silent treatment ends, e.g. wife joined me for breakfast this morning and started talking normally, as if nothing had happened over the past two weeks.

Do I also pretend that nothing happened? This seems counter intuitive. I also worry that when I try to set a boundary, there will be a denial that there ever was this silent treatment.

Or do I point out that what she was doing wasn't lost on me. This carries the risk that she will see that her punishment of was having an effect and may re-inforce the behaviour.

Which of the two evils is lesser ?

I would advise simply going about your life. The less it impacts you, the less interest she will have in using it again, against you. Have fun when shes quiet...at least there isnt rging,. ya? Live your life and let her have her " hold my breath until I turn blue" moment. Dont give it attention, before, during, or after..and get busy so that it wont impact you.

Keep in mind, what you have done in the past hasnt worked, has it? So..pretend shes 4 and pouting..and go on with your life.

Steph
Logged



jardin
*****
Offline Offline

Posts: 874



« Reply #5 on: April 28, 2011, 11:44:55 PM »

Maybe I didnt ask the question clearly, it was about what to do when you are getting clear signals that the silent treatment is ending.

I understand now that feeling sorry for yourself this whole period and allowing yourself to be punished is not a good idea. (Why I didn't figure this out over the 7 years now seems like such a waste)

But what to do when the silent treatment ends, e.g. wife joined me for breakfast this morning and started talking normally, as if nothing had happened over the past two weeks.

Do I also pretend that nothing happened? This seems counter intuitive. I also worry that when I try to set a boundary, there will be a denial that there ever was this silent treatment.

Or do I point out that what she was doing wasn't lost on me. This carries the risk that she will see that her punishment of was having an effect and may re-inforce the behaviour.

Which of the two evils is lesser ?

Can you find a middle ground between these two perspectives?  Right now, she is coming down, stabilizing.  By forcing a conversation or imposing your feelings on her, you weaken the foundation that she is slowly working to re-build.  If she's not ready for the conversation, almost anything you say will be invalidating and she very well may respond with more anger...or more silence. 

On the other hand, at some point, it very well may be appropriate to address this behavior.  After time, and when things get back to some level of calm, it may be completely ok to say to her...you know, I'd like to talk about something...I care about your feelings and I know sometimes you get very upset and need some time to yourself; when those times happen, I am ok, but I still need you to at least be responsive to conversations about (kids, home, work, etc). 

At the right time and place, she can be receptive to this.  It doesn't mean that she won't get upset at some level, but she will be better able to hear it.  As long as you stay calm and don't defend your need, things may generally remain ok.  In contrast, at this time, she may be very quick to defense, very on guard.  Hearing you may be very hard and what's the point in talking if the recipient isn't there to hear.  So, the question is, can you let this sit until the right time?  Until you regain some closeness and calm?  That is not walking on eggshells, it's being smart and it's accepting and respecting the constraints of the relationship. 
Logged

Our integrity sells for so little, but it is all we really have.  It is the very last inch of us.  And within that inch, we are free. - Valerie's Letter


2017 Financial Sponsors
Thank you. We are all appreciative of the thoughtful and responsible men and women who provide the support, education, and brotherhood to keep BPDFamily on the air and make a difference in the lives and families of many. To all, thank you for this wonderful resource.
akv
Aletheia
alf
antony_james
ArleighBurke
At_Bay
Aussieman
Avi
Axial
azbubba
babyducks
baconeggs
Barny1705
bearhunter
berry
bestintentions
bigredneck
bigsis
blackstone
bpdmom99
braveSun
BStrong
busybee1116
Calm Waters
Caroled
Cat Familiar
cherisw
chobers
Chosen
chump
cj488
cjames
Clearmind
cleotokos
Cmjo
Cole
Confused1234
confusedhubby
Conundrum
coworkerfriend
cricket
Curiously1
Darsha500
DearBFF
Deb
Dizzy Princess
DoxieLover
drained1996
duncsvoice
Dutched
earlgrey
Eye438
F150
Finding Courage
Findingmysong723
flubber767
FlyFish
Foolishwizdom
ForeverDad
Fr4nz
Frank88
Free One
fromheeltoheal
Gagrl
gettingoverit
Gift to myself
gloveman
Gorges
half-life
HappyChappy
Harmless
HarposGal
Harri
havana
Healthy88
Homefree
HopefulDad
HopefulPapaOf2
img001
incadove
InIndia
inwardliberation
isseeu
its_rosie
JaneStorm
Japeslee
jasmine-1234
jellibeans
JerryRG
jo19854
joeramabeme
JohnSmith2016
JulesC
KansasDad
kc sunshine
Keep
kentavr3
kiddfei
kim peter
knowingmyself
Kowalski
laker
Larmoyant
Leaf
Learning Fast
letgogirl
little doggy
lovenature
lucylou
luter
malibu4x
maple
Mars22
maryy16
mavis
maxen
Me-Time
meanlittleface
Meili
Memorial Donation
mggt
Mimmo
mitatsu
MP2
mscj
Mutt
narcdaughter2
nevaeh
newlyhopeful
ninjacat
NorthernGirl
ou81201370
P.F.Change
PaGuy
PaulaJeanne
PDQuick
Pedros28
Penumbra66
Phoenix
Pilpel
PinkieV
Pipedreamer25
pr0gressnotperfecti0n
Prim808
Purged
Qcarolr
Quama
RAPIDclassic1
Rapt Reader
RDMercer55
Recycle
rfriesen
Ridingthewaves
Roselee
RunningWithScissors
rzr14
Sad4mydad
Sadly
samanthal
samuell
sanemom
Scarlet Phoenix
Scrabble
seeperplexed
SES
sidra36
SilentObserver
Skip
Slipping
Sluggo
Someday . . .
Soniab72
StandingTall
steelwork
stellaris
stimpy
stockholmama
supermum
Survived
swampped
SweetCharlotte
sweetheart
T2H
tbddbt
Tea Fish
The Teacher
Theo41
TheraminFlick
thisagain
TigerEye
Tippy
trytrytry
Turkish
ugghh
UndauntedDad
VitaminC
volumetwo
wchi
wendydarling
WhatJustHappened?
WhatShouldIDo
Whichwayisup
whirlpoollife
WhoMe51
william3693
winston72
worn_out
yaffle
yamada
Yaryar87
zaqsert

Pay it forward Here

Pages: [1]   Go Up
  Print  
 
Jump to:  



Study the thought patterns and inclinations of a BPD spouse, girlfriend, or boyfriend. Learn relationship building and learn communication skills and strategies for personal growth.

Welcome
READ BEFORE POSTING
Make your first post

Take the pledge
Tell us your story

Perspective Articles
The big picture
Is it BPD?
What does it take to make it?

What is the first step?
[Basic Tools]
Wisemind
Ending Conflict
Listen with Empathy
Don't be Invalidating
Setting Boundaries

Lessons

1 Understanding your partner’s behaviors.

2 Understanding your role in the relationship.

3 Tools: communication validation, and reinforcement of good behavior.

4 Surviving  confrontation and disrespect.

5 Finding inner strength and hope.

6 When everything else fails.


Workshops
Participate Here

Frequently asked questions
... about BPD.
... about using the board.


Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.21 | SMF © 2006-2017, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!