Oh my! I'm sorry that your d is having these thoughts and feelings. It is so difficult to know our children are in that much pain.
I can see that the isolation would be a good thing in that exposing her to peers who are also suicidal could make things worse for her. I can also see the other side of the situation in that teens are hungry for acceptance amongst their group. Having the opportunity to identify with others around her age could ease the feelings of shame/being alone/enigma.
Policies are hard to get past in the medical world. I think any long term exposure to them needs to be a good fit for the individual. Flexibility can cover a multitude of scenarios and patient needs. The goal of the facility is to keep your d safe from herself. I guess they accomplish that so there is value there. How they accomplish it may be questionable for some of their patients.
Making the hospital experience unpleasant to discourage using them as an escape makes sense. This could also backfire in that the next time a patient is suicidal they will not speak /ask for help because they don't want to repeat an unpleasant experience at the hospital.
Most choices have both good and bad consequences. Keeping the overall picture in mind... .not losing sight of the goal at hand... .can be difficult in times of crisis and even day to day. You made the best choice with the resources available to you BioAdoptmom3.
Regarding asking a young person's desires for medication is a good thing I believe. Helping them is something we want to do with them... .not to them. It is also true that asking an unstable/mentally ill person to make decisions about their meds or professional care is a risky venture no matter what their age. It defies logic and reason and there is little that can be done against their will past a certain age (depending on where you live). The laws hold us accountable for them while the law ties our hands behind our backs to help them. What a conundrum.
Remaining calm and firm with the professionals, listening to the reasoning for their policies and validating the value of those policies before presenting to them the other side (your personal opinions) may affect positive change or may not. It is out of your control.
Have you read this information?
Depression and Suicidal IdeationTOOLS: Dealing with threats of Suicide and Suicide AttemptsI hope that you find something there that can help you and your family.
Knowing prior to crisis what your options are and how to calmly respond is vital for everyone's well being and making wise choices in the moment.
Let us know how you and your d14 are doing.
lbjnltx