Hi SVC;
I get such helpful advice on here, but struggle so much in living it.
I hope you know that many of us, including staff, including myself, have the same experience. I experience myself offering peer support about tools and approaches to improve relationships, yet then experience myself not applying it in my own life. I struggle with feeling shame about that, and I could see how you could also feel mad at yourself in that situation. Know that you're not alone.
My perception of myself is that because I so lack confidence in parenting decisions around my BPD kid, I feel cold and unloving in my reactions when I do something different than before.. I waffle because I’m unsure, and of course, that’s the worst thing I could do.
Tell me some more about that. Am I following with you that in the past, you'd maybe be more "supportive" and that felt to you like being warm and loving, and now that you're trying new approaches, you feel like you're behaving icily/rigidly/"stiff-arming" towards her?
Is it the ability to follow your own rules for your own life (have boundaries for yourself) while also expressing warmth and care for her, that is difficult? Or is that kind of off the mark?
How do you all manage the guilt. I know it’s common and unwarranted in many cases, but I’m talking practically. Do you do affirmations? Read something? Tell a therapist? I know the guilt is useless and hindering and I still find myself unable to let it go emotionally. It’s hurting me and her. I feel stuck.
Talking with a therapist has been really important.
While my husband's kids' don't have BPD, their mom has many traits, and so I can relate to your general situation of "trying to parent young adult children when BPD is in the family system". They are 17 & 19 so while in a sense we're on the home stretch, we are not out of it by any means.
Discussing parenting/stepparenting is still triggering for both of us. It has been years of stress and pain, and while our legal ties to the kids' mom end in (checks calendar) about 11 months, I don't think H and I are anywhere near being able to process the trauma together.
I have been able to process some very guilt-laden memories with my T -- times I deeply regret the stepparenting choices I made, choices that seem like they contributed to the kids' pain and trauma.
After processing with my T, I can sometimes think of those memories "in the wild" (i.e. not in therapy) and do OK with kind of a fleeting memory, but it still hurts and if I think about it too much, it's overwhelming.
One thing that was helpful in therapy was my T understanding and normalizing for me how abnormal and dysfunctional the situation has been. That a lot of what I did and went through was the best anyone could've done under the circumstances. Not sure how to describe it better -- but it has been really helpful to hear her say "you know what, the situation was so extreme, so abnormal, so beyond normal parenting, that of course you're still feeling _____".
Otherwise, I would probably be spiraling in shame and guilt. So it helps to be reminded that yes, the chaos and trauma are kind of still going on, and so it makes sense that I'm really not up for deep work on my own past, because current life isn't really safe or stable enough for that yet. And for me, that's where a lot of the guilt comes from: "I should be working on myself, for the kids' sake", and when I'm not "working on myself", when I'm avoiding bringing up stuff in therapy, I do feel a lot of guilt and shame. My T has helped me put that in perspective -- those are normal things to feel, and anyone would feel that, under the circumstances, and I don't need to be "doing better".
I am only occasionally able to self-affirm, and it's rarely about interpersonal/family relationships. I do a great job validating myself when I'm trying to make it to the bus on time ("all you can do is your own personal best") or grocery shopping ("you're doing great following the list"),

It is a bigger step to validate/affirm myself about family interactions, but I wonder if you can do something similar -- start practicing self-validation in areas where it feels natural and authentic and achievable, just to build those brain pathways.
Are there things you are doing in life, that you feel like you could genuinely validate? It could be about your BPDd, but wouldn't have to be.
Can you self-validate about coming here and being honest? "I did the best I could to share that I was mad at myself. I did a good job being open about my feelings".
We can't always resolve the bigger feelings right away -- at least for me, that's the case. It's going to be a long process, and when BPD-related chaos is still active, we may need to accept that we have to tolerate unresolved feelings for a bit. Or, we may find that the therapy session is a safe enough place for us to process those feelings and then return to "real life". Could be worth a try, if you aren't already seeing a T.
You're definitely not the only one struggling with the challenge of feeling upset about the disconnect between learning new approaches, and living them out
