Oh
Jefferson , I completely understand your feelings!
This period of being estranged from our daughter is now going into its 5th year. She started running away when she was just 12. She is now 54 and I can't tell you how many times in the years in between we have been cut out of her life and even more sadly, out of the lives of our only 2 grandchildren. In the earlier years the estrangements were never this long but then she was a single mother with financial and emotional issues and we worked hard to fill in the gaps. No need for that kind of support now so no great need for us. In a perfect world, at our age, this would be our time to be comforted and supported.
I, too, think of what a reconcilliation would bring at this point. In all honesty, I am tired. I am not wanting to get on the roller coaster again. Just last night my husband and I were talking about the calmness that has been in our lives for these past few years. Well, there have been a few bursts of caustic emails from her...coming out of the blue because of...? I learned too late not to respond...not to J-A-D-E (Justifty-Argue-Deny-Explain). Like you, my response has been "I love you"...but lately I don't even want to do that. I've said/written it many times...meant it each time...still do...always will.
So, Jefferson, you are in a much younger age bracket than me...more time to work on skills. Had I had the tools way back when to deal with her BPD-like behaviours, perhaps this would not be my story now. Whatever! It IS what it is...now getting on with life.
Kudos to you for having a therapist!

Also, you have the support of your husband and of other children. That, unfortunately was not in my case. Our only other child has issues of his own. My husband was never the target of our daughter's wrath so wondered why I couldn't just let her barbs roll off my back. (Oh so easy for him to say!

...

) Twice over the years he consented to go to counselling with me over this issue. Both times he walked in confidently...both times he walked out silent and pensive. I, though, had my feelings validated and was more empowered to carry on. We have created more of a balance in our relationship and life is pretty good for us now.
You hang in there, fellow Mom! Keep doing your homework...keep coming back to voice your heart and your hurts then help others here with theirs. By all means, keep your therapist on speed dial! This is your journey and you should be in control of it, not your daughter. Keep your eyes set on your happiness, your well-being. What will follow is more of an ability for you to tend and care to those around you. Be confident that you have always done your best...did better when you knew better...and, no doubt, will continue to do so. Set yourself up as a role model for that troubled child of yours.
Here is to better and better days for all of us.
Huat