new bf says he makes ex's sign an NDA

[anonymousgf]

I don't even know what to make of this... obviously its a red flag I know. After almost a year of knowing each other, he asked me to be his girlfriend 2 days ago. Last night we went out and had a few drinks. While we were eating, he told me that with every ex boyfriend or girlfriend that he has had, at the end of the relationship he paid them $20,000 to sign an NDA. He is well off and extremely secretive/ hard to get to know so its definitely possible. Is this just fear of abandonment turning into containment or is he trying to hide his past behavior? I told him I wouldn't sign it and he told me that I would sign it because he has a lot of connections and would make my life harder if I didn't sign it. He told me that he does it because he is worried about his reputation. Is signing an NDA really normal for wealthy people?

[RELATIONSHIP PROBLEM SOLVING]

RELATIONSHIP PROBLEM SOLVING This is a high level discussion board for solving ongoing, day-to-day relationship conflicts. Members are welcomed to express frustration but must seek constructive solutions to problems. This is not a place for relationship "stay" or "leave" discussions. Please read the specific guidelines for this group.

[Pook075]

I don't even know what to make of this... obviously its a red flag I know. After almost a year of knowing each other, he asked me to be his girlfriend 2 days ago. Last night we went out and had a few drinks. While we were eating, he told me that with every ex boyfriend or girlfriend that he has had, at the end of the relationship he paid them $20,000 to sign an NDA. He is well off and extremely secretive/ hard to get to know so its definitely possible. Is this just fear of abandonment turning into containment or is he trying to hide his past behavior? I told him I wouldn't sign it and he told me that I would sign it because he has a lot of connections and would make my life harder if I didn't sign it. He told me that he does it because he is worried about his reputation. Is signing an NDA really normal for wealthy people?

Hello and welcome to the family!  NDA's are more common for wealthy individuals, especially in business, so it's not completely unheard of.  It is a bit strange bringing it up at the start of a relationship that you'll sign one at the end.

I've had many clients in the past though that wouldn't have a single conversation until we both signed NDAs.  One turned out to be a billionaire who was in a lawsuit with one of the most powerful families on Earth...I never would have guessed that beforehand.  The NDA allowed us to speak freely though about his company, their strategy, and some trade secrets he was filing patents on; there was no way I could have worked with him otherwise.  He did this because previous employees who didn't sign NDAs were bribed by the powerful family to share those trade secrets.

Anyway, this is normal for business and it's semi-normal for relationships by people focused on business and wealth.  It is also a major red flag though where his priorities lie, so I'd be very careful.

[ForeverDad]

It sounds strange that he would be able to force NDA signing of an ending or ended relationship.  Where would the legal leverage be afterward?  At a guess, I'd figure that's where the $20K comes in as incentive?

I doubt a NDA would be applicable for illegal or abusive actions.  Sounds like he wants to have his fun - and avoid negative social posts, etc - even when planning to walk away?

[Alex V]

What does your gut feeling tell you? Or is you asking here perhaps giving the answer. You may ask yourself what needs to be covered up by this NDA. It does not sound like a base of trust to start a relationship like this. And treatening you if you don't sign? Be careful.

[Skip]

Is signing an NDA really normal for wealthy people?

To be binding, an NDA lists explicitly what is not to be disclosed. If he wants you to agree not to disclose the names of his business clients that's one thing, if he doesn't want you to tell anyone that he was physically abusive, that is another. If he is willing to pay someone $20,000 not to disclose business information, many people would take that.

he told me that I would sign it because he has a lot of connections and would make my life harder if I didn't sign it.

This is intimidation/control. He may be testing/grooming your boundaries by using a carrot ($20,000) and a stick (intimidation) to see how you react.

[Under The Bridge]

he told me that I would sign it because he has a lot of connections and would make my life harder if I didn't sign it.

That one massive line alone would have decided it for me. Threats are a no-no.
That didn't just sound like a business-type NDA, more like a very controlling life 'NDA'.

As others have said, go with your gut feeling and tread very carefully.

[Rowdy]

That one massive line alone would have decided it for me. Threats are a no-no.
That didn't just sound like a business-type NDA, more like a very controlling life 'NDA'.

As others have said, go with your gut feeling and tread very carefully.

hmmm, sounds all a bit P Didley to me.
Why does he want people to sign NDA’s in personal relationships, sounds like he gets involved in risky or shady behaviours that he doesn’t want made common knowledge once the relationship ends and to be brutally honest, it sounds like it will at some point.

And where does that lead. There might be situations you are put in that leads you to feelings of guilt, anxiety, depression.
Then you may end up with an overbearing weight that you need to get off your chest, yet you can’t talk to anyone because of the threat of making your life difficult, and anyone that might approach you questioning your relationship with him will make you wonder if they are flying monkeys, and then you end up with feelings of paranoia. So your health could suffer.

You don’t just find $20k down the back of a sofa, all of those dollar bills will have strings attached.

[CC43]

Hi there,

I'd say, go with your gut on this one.  I find the threats and intimidation to be very off-putting.  I've signed dozens if not over a hundred NDAs in business and employment dealings, but I was never, ever forced to sign anything.  You could say as much:  I'm not comfortable being forced to sign anything.  Another way to say this could be:  I'll have my lawyer look at it if and when the time comes.  If he asks you to name a lawyer, just say you have a trusted cousin, uncle or colleague, something vague.  He shouldn't balk at that response because it's customary to have lawyers review any important documents before signature.

But it sounds a little to me like this guy is bragging.  He thinks he's so important he needs you to sign an NDA?  He's willing to pay you 20 grand to get you to sign it?  He's paid past ex-girlfriends to do this?  It sounds to me like he's overcompensating for his insecurities, as well as treating girlfriends like commodities to be purchased, coerced and/or discarded.

[Notwendy]

I didn't read the book or see the movie but heard it talked about. The character Christian Grey (as in 50 shades) had his partners sign an NDA.

But this guy is also paying people to sign and threatened you if you didn't sign it.

Makes me wonder what did this guy do to his exes that he has to pay them to  sign an NDA to not talk about.  And if so- do you want him to do this to you?

The other possibility is that it's BS and he's delusional. But if so, do you want that too?

The only situation where I could think of this being a legitimate concern for him is if he's a well known celebrity and doesn't want his private life sold to the tabloids by an ex. But celebrities may also be creepers in private.

I think the best take is that people who have nothing to hide in romantic relationships would have no need for an NDA.

[Skip]

Setting the threatening aspect aside for a moment…

Breakups can be messy for many reasons. In my 20 years of reading here, I’ve seen some extremely vindictive post-relationship behavior—from both our members and their former partners. The concept of an NDA, by itself, is not a character flaw. In some situations, it can be a prudent precaution.

What I find interesting—and potentially credible—is that he does not seek an NDA upfront, but rather at the end of the relationship, when a partner would theoretically have the most leverage if he had behaved badly. He is also offering $20,000—an amount that would be difficult to refuse if there were no foul play on his part, yet insufficient if there were serious misconduct.

That suggests the NDA may be intended primarily to protect against vindictive behavior after a breakup—such as contacting his employer, his children, or posting identifying or damaging information online—rather than to conceal serious wrongdoing.

One reasonable step would be to ask to review a copy of a prior NDA, with names and dates redacted, to better understand its scope and intent.

[Skip]

Just a small comment on "follow your gut". We often encourage members to rather "be mindful" for complex things like this.

Key Differences at a Glance

Aspect----------------- Follow Gut    Be Mindful

Speed------------------- Fast, instinctive    Slower, deliberate

Basis    Intuition, emotion, pattern recognition    Awareness, observation, reflection

Best for    Time-pressured or familiar situations    Complex, emotional, or high-stakes decisions

Main risk    Bias, projection    Overthinking, indecision