Hey NonBPDEx,
I want to echo Cat Familiar.
Then one day she came home and blurted out "this is not working, neither of us are happy, and neither of us trust each other".
You have to figure out what is not working in the r/s. This is a good time to self reflect and think carefully about what is not working.
You mentioned that this is the third time. I don’t know your backstory but a lot of us can relate with your situation. Some times we fall into r/s patterns and wait for our partners to warm up to us again and go through the same routine.
Her Facebook profile status is a good sign for you it means that she doesn’t think of you in a complete negative way. What I mean is in the current emotional state that she is in meaning that how she thinks about you is not all negative thoughts and feelings. If she has nothing but negating thoughts and feelings bout you when she thinks about you it’s going to take a longer time time for her to let go of those feelings.
Asking her to change her profile status is going to telegraph that you haven’t sorted out what is wrong in the r/s and is not going to conjure positive thoughts about you - it is going to work against you.
If you’re wanting to move forward give her space and take this time to work on yourself.
What do you think could use some work on your r/s?